Thursday, March 5, 2009

Review of Documentary: "Green"



Summary


The documentary "Green", is based on over 150 petrochemical plants that run along the Mississippi river from Baton Rouge to New Orleans. This one area that ranges around 100 miles in 25% responsible for the nations petrochemicals, also known as "Cancer Alley".


Throughout the documentary, they move along the river from town to town and discuss what issues each are facing. Most share the same things in common, low-income residents and an unusual amount of rare cancer cases and other rare health issues- Linked to the plants? It's hard to prove. People who are interviewed and live in these towns (cancer alley towns) are confident that there is a link between their health and the plants. A young girl talks about her cancer and how she believes it related to the plants. She suffers from neuroblastoma- Tumors. She has had numerous removed and she is only 13 years old. Another case that was discussed involed a little boy named Caleb whos face was paralyzed on the left side from cancer of the brain. He needed radiation, during which had his pituitary gland "fried". This caused his growth to be affected and he now has serious developmental problems.

There are so many other people affected, I could write the longest blog ever and not get the words out to describe how these people are feeling or what they are going through. Apparently, these big cooperations keep track of their own data and have to (should) disclose when there is a problem. The example related to this kind of situation was, turning yourself in for a speeding ticket, only this is a little more serious. Another issue that seemed a little shady was data can easily be skewed because of the division of land. Why lie to our selves with these numbers? We are only manipulating ourselves in the long run.

A town called Norco was hit pretty hard with power plant problems. The coorporation Shell had an explosion at one of their plants. Seven people died. A powerplant "flare", which releases gasses and toxins into the airhad a mishap, but it was ok... The plant gave the town a better look and offered them money. Seriouly!?

What about a 700 million dollar plant? Shin Tek, a plant that is known for its use of polyvinyl chloride (pvc's). Thats ok too, because it will offer 650 jobs and open up ecomonic opportunities. When interviewed about that statement a woman of that town said, "Certain people are sacrificed for power and greed!" Which I believe is true. People can't see past the money. If something is producing and making profit, then it must be a good thing.

My thoughts..

Is there really nothing we can do? Will there always be enivronmental injustice? It's hard to say. A point made, was that us as the consumers are the ones feeding the plants the $$$ to keep them going. Can we go without those products? It's such a nasty cycle of taking a lot and not giving anything. It works for everyone who are not fimiliar with these issues, we live our lives day to day and think the smallest issues are tough,. I couldn't imagine having to live on a 17 foot deep landfill, or lose a child to cancer that could have been linked to a home grown garden. So many things are taken for granted. A woman on the documentary said a very powerful comment, " They don't see human beings, the see GREEN!" Until we can look past the "green", problems are going to keep on rising.






23 comments:

  1. Sara,
    Good review, it's very disturbing that as a country we allow these places to keep running when officials know that it is negatively effecting the environment and more importantly the people living nearby.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sara, in the section where you mentioned thoughts that challenged your thinking, something sparked my thinking as well.
    You said you couldn't imagine having to lose a child to a rare form of cancer, or to live on top of a 17 food landfill...
    After reading some of our peers environmental working group eye-openers I read phrases such as "I just can't live without my _______".
    I think we all have a twisted view on what is actually important in life.
    Great Review! --S

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sara j, you brought up a really valid point here and it is sad to think of what we consider important, when people are loosing their lives for such unbelievable reasons. Now, refering to the post, Sara I really liked how your tlaked about the "flare" it was unreal to me that people were living right next to this... can you imagine? Then seven people die and the spokes person women... says well the company has a new look now? huh? crazy! great review this week Sara!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great post Tool. You touched on really important issues brought up in this documentary, and many of which I found heart wrenching as well. To know lives are being lost and transformed from what these plants are doing....all in the name of money. That is hard for me to swallow. But I guess all we can do is make sure we decide differently, and actively work to make a difference so this phenomenon can be slowed someday. You did a great job :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great summary of the film! I liked how you added the quote "They don't see human beings, the see GREEN!" I definitely agree with you when you said until we look past the "green" problems are going keep coming. Isn't it sad when all people care about is the "green?" Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great post! I agree that we seem to be stuck in a vicious cycle of buying these plastic/chemical products that are produced at the expensive of other people. Also, thanks for putting things in perspective for us by pointing out the horrors of having to lose a child to cancer or live on a landfill... it makes me really appreciate the home I have here in Duluth.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I too could not imagine living on a 17 foot landfill or losing a child or any family member to cancer because of something that they might have eaten from a home garden... My family did a lot of gardening when I was younger and to think that those foods I was eating would affect me more negatively than the fruit and vegetables in a grocery store would be rather surprising... People shouldn't have to worry about things like that!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Sara
    Good review! I think I liked this documentary so much because of the people that were interviewed. I cannot even imagine having either of the cancers that were discussed in the documentary. It's terrible to think about. Sara J: You are right, we really are ridiculous. I say that SO much. It's bad of me I know, but when you've always had it, it's hard to think of your life without it. Great ideas ladies!

    Heather

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hey Sara!
    I liked reading this review, I can tell you put a lot of thought into this!
    I also think I could write the longest blog ever and not even begin to describe what these families are going through! It was so heart breaking gto see and hear the stories of the people who are from this area! and I like the analogy about turning yourself in for a speeding ticket! No one is going to do that!! I also agree that so many things are taken for granted and as Sara J's comment above says, it brought up a good thought and correlates with what you said about people taking the smallest problem and making it the biggest deal! I think America as a whole really does have a twisted image of what is really important in life! It's like "you don't know what you have until it's gone."
    Great post Sara! Really got me thinking!!

    Kathy

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great post Sara!
    This really got me thinking. What is it that is important in life? Why do people always complain(including me) of the little things that do not matter in life. This film and class has definitely opened my eyes to what i need to focus on in life. Good job:)

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hey Sara!
    good post. when you said that you couldnt imagine living on a 17 foot deep landfill. It got me thinking about the interviews they were doing when talking about that. The solution they came up for that (removing 2 feet of the landfill) is just an easy way out for the companies. Its sad to think that those people are struggling just stay healthy.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Great job Sara! I really liked reading your summary! You really seemed to nail the main issues of this documentary. I really liked how you added your own question about the topics you were writing about, and how you made it very clear that what the movie was saying was completely bogus. I especially like how you described the explosion at the power plant in Narco. The documentary explained that unfortunately eight people died, but at least the plant gave the town a better look and offered them money to make up for the explosion. This is ridiculous. I also really liked the quote that you finished your post with that talked about how businesses don't see people, they see GREEN.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Nice job Sara! It is sad to think that these companies believe that what they are doing is ok and not sacrificing the lives of people in nearby towns. Obviously having these chemical plants near these towns is causing a greater number of illnesses in people. All you have to do is look at the before and after picture of the arrival with these chemical plants.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Good question, to me it does seem like there will always be environmental injustice, and other environmental problems. Nothing can ever be perfect in this world, but we can do a lot to try to make things better. You're right, it is harder to it is harder to take action when we don't live close to areas like these. It's very sad how the EPA isn't doing much to stand after these people.
    Nice review!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Sara,

    I completely agree with you on your last statement, that no solutions will rise until we can look past the "green." I couldn't imagine living in some of the conditions the people in/near cancer valley were living in. Not even being able to garden because the soil is so toxic?? I think that alone is a strong enough reason for the gov't to step up and take action. Not only the gov't but also the people. Like you said, consumers are the main driving force behind these corporations, so if we can all somehow use less products, maybe, just MAYBE we can help change the name of "cancer valley" to "hope valley."

    ReplyDelete
  16. It seems inhumane that the government even lets people live by these plants! I thought this film was really sad that cancer was affecting children and people all around the town. There has to be something that can be done!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Great review Sara, I also couldn't imagine having to live on a 17 foot deep landfill, or lose a child to cancer that could have been linked to a home grown garden!!! There seems to be so many things that we take for granted. I'm glad that we now know about this situation,and hopefully we can raise awareness to reduce the use of plastics=)

    ReplyDelete
  18. Sara, I thought you did a great job of including links throughout your text. I thought you made some very significant statements: "Another issue that seemed a little shady was data can easily be skewed because of the division of land. Why lie to our selves with these numbers? We are only manipulating ourselves in the long run." You are right! In the end, the government is going to end up hurting their own members with no one to blame but themselves.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Sara~
    Great Post!! I too thought it was crazy that people were living in a landfill Just think of what is going into the water...its no wonder that people are getting cancer and all other kinds of diseases too! Keep up the great work!!

    ReplyDelete
  20. Sara-
    Good thoughts! It is hard to think that we are the people feeding the plants money that are hurting these people. It is just a vicious cycle and something really does need to be done about it. I never really thought of it in the way that we are supporting the plants! I think it is something that a lot of people aren't aware of!! Good Post!!:)

    ReplyDelete
  21. Good review! The way the people are being treated in the documentary is wrong, you can't set up housing on a landfill and expect it to be healthy and from what I learned we need to do more about environmental injustice.

    ReplyDelete
  22. It is true that money can blind a person to the true issues at hand. I hope that each child that had a medical condition can make it out okay. Going through radiation treatments is never a fun time. The Narco plant disaster was not fun to hear about either. With employees dying. Overall it seems to me that these chemical plants are built too close to civilization, and the employees of the plants should wear a lot of protective clothing. Just think about the wildlife near these facilities must be dying off like everywhere you look.

    ReplyDelete
  23. this was a sad documentary. I don't know why all of these plants are all in the same area. It seams like you're asking for bad things to happen when all of these plants are in such a small area.

    ReplyDelete